There’s nothing better than a comeback story, and Melvin Gordon could write an all-timer

Oct 4, 2022, 8:30 AM
Melvin Gordon III...
(Photo by Jamie Schwaberow/Getty Images)
(Photo by Jamie Schwaberow/Getty Images)

In the NFL, kicking someone when they’re down is as much of a sport as football itself.

One need only turn on the radio, cue up a podcast or log on to social media to experience this in action with Melvin Gordon since his fourth fumble of the season Sunday.

But there’s one thing people love more than that:

A comeback story.

And thanks to Williams’ injury, he will likely get the opportunity to author it.



Start here: It can’t get worse.

Consider this: It has been 21 years since a running back, fullback or wide receiver had four fumbles in the first four games — and did so with as few touches as the 45 Gordon has so far this season, per data compiled from

Last year, Gordon had three fumbles — and the third didn’t come until his 231st and final touch of the campaign.

That fumble came on the same day as a 47-yard touchdown sprint and his third 100-yard game of the season. Those accomplishments serve as a reminder of why Gordon offers hope, despite the fumbles.

Gordon’s previous two Broncos seasons saw the second- and third-highest per-carry averages of his career. In terms of navigating through tight spaces, he’s strengthened as he approaches his 30th birthday next April.

Gordon remains a highly effective runner — as long as he doesn’t lose the football.

That’s the big “if,” of course.

There is a strange freedom to where Gordon sits now. For one thing, the fumbling trend cannot get worse than five fumbles in five games. Had Javonte Williams not been injured, it’s unlikely he would been in position for it to become six in six.

But Williams’ season is now over. And as a result, Gordon could get chances that might not have come his way under normal circumstances, the type that usually only come in baseball, with its trust of the broad sample size the sport provides.



If Gordon’s ball security ascends to even what his normal rate was before this ghastly opening four games of 2022, he could be poised to author one of the greatest comebacks in Broncos history.

Gordon’s fumble rate this year is ghastly: one every 11.3 touches. In the previous two seasons as a Bronco was one every 68.3. That was not great, but not backbreaking, either.

The league average among players with at least 100 total touches on returns and offense since 2020 is one every 81.6 touches. Among those 222 players, 28 have worse fumble rates than Gordon’s in that span (1 every 47.5 touches).

Some of those players include:

  • San Francisco WR Deebo Samuel, 1 fumble every 35.2 touches
  • Cincinnati WR Ja’Marr Chase, 1 fumble every 38.7 touches
  • Kansas City WR JuJu Smith-Schuster, 1 fumble every 26.8 touches
  • Denver WR Jerry Jeudy, 1 fumble every 34.7 touches

Yes, Gordon doesn’t even have the worst fumble rate on the Broncos over the last three years.

And before this season, his 2020-21 rate of one fumble every 68.3 touches was worse than average, but better than 74 players of the afore-mentioned 222.

Gordon is in a slump. But the statistical likelihood is that he will ascend closer to his mean — if not of his career rate of one fumble every 88 touches, which he had prior to Week 18 of last season, then certainly to his rate as a Bronco.

And if that happens, the rest of Gordon’s game is intact.

Even on the doomed run Sunday, that was apparent. He hit the gap quickly and knifed through contact. And as mentioned in a previous piece, he remains an effective short-yardage, goal-to-go runner.

The chances will be there.



Gordon isn’t the only mid-to-late-career veteran RB in the room anymore.

The Broncos signed Latavius Murray from New Orleans’ practice squad Monday. There are precious few 32-year-old running backs rambling about pro football these days. Murray’s status as one of them demonstrates his professional survival skills.

But Murray will have to get up to speed first.

In the meantime, Gordon will have more chances. And an opportunity to give Broncos Country the thing it loves more than anger — the chance to witness redemption.

Comeback Player of the Year? If Gordon ascends to his mean when it comes to ball security, there’s no reason why he can’t make it happen.



Peyton Manning...
James Merilatt

Greg Penner needs to give Broncos Country a “Prime” moment

With a sixth-straight losing season now official, it's time for the owner to make a bold move that will galvanize the fan base and provide hope
15 hours ago
Patrick Mahomes...
Jake Shapiro

Oddsmakers make Broncos huge home underdogs against rival Chiefs

The Broncos haven't won in forever, this season or against the Chiefs and they're hosting KC; it's unlikely it'll be a win for the home team
15 hours ago
Coach Prime...
Cecil Lammey

Mile High Monday: Prime thankfully takes attention away from Broncos

As the Broncos sputtered to another disappointing loss, the Buffaloes stole the spotlight when they introduced Deion Sanders as head coach
15 hours ago
russell wilson...
James Merilatt

Ugly loss to the Ravens won’t be the low point for sad-sack Broncos

On the heels of their worst performance of a dismal season, Denver is heading headfirst into a showdown with Kansas City that could be ugly
15 hours ago
D.J. Jones...
Cecil Lammey

Three observations from the Broncos loss to the Ravens in Week 13

The Broncos offense continues to embarrass, and this team has no identity on that side of the ball, as proven yet again by their nine points on Sunday
15 hours ago
Russell Wilson...
Andrew Mason

It came down to the Broncos’ defense — because the offense is a tire fire

As Denver's offense plumbs new depths in a generationally bad season, its defense has no margin for error.
2 days ago
There’s nothing better than a comeback story, and Melvin Gordon could write an all-timer