Could Cale Makar go down as the greatest defenseman ever?

May 10, 2022, 12:10 PM
Cale Makar...
Photo by Mickey Bernal/Getty Images

Does Cale Makar belong in the same breath as Bobby Orr?

Nathan MacKinnon thinks one day, his young teammate could be recognized on the same level as Orr, who is considered the best NHL d-man of all time.

“He might be the best player in the league right now,” MacKinnon, a two-time All-Star, said. “The way he dominates from the back end is amazing. All season but this playoffs is he’s taking another step with his leadership in the room. Be more vocal and obviously on the ice is so dominant.”

Makar finally got a full regular season and tallied 86 points. But as MacKinnon eluded to, he’s stepped up to another level in the Stanley Cup Playoffs. Makar has 10 points in the Colorado Avalanche’s first four playoff games, an NHL record for most points by a d-man in the first four games of a postseason run.

“He might be one of the best d-men to ever play by the end of his career at this rate,” MacKinnon said. So really excited to have him on our team.”

Makar has already played 39 playoff games across four years after debuting in the 2019 postseason. He’s put more than a point per game. This season it’s become clear he’s one of the better skaters in the league, circling the Predators like prey during the four-game sweep. Makar recorded 41 shot attempts in the series, which is third-best among all players in the NHL playoffs this season. MacKinnon paces that stat with 44.

Makar has been impressive, but the Orr category is on another level. Makar has been a point-per-game player in his career, Orr played 10 seasons in Boston and finished with 888 points. He carried over into the postseason, notching 92 points in 74 games, helping the Bruins win two Stanley Cups. Orr won eight Norris Trophies, three Hart Trophies, and two Conn Smythes.

Orr is simply the standard. Though, he is from another time so it’s hard to compare Makar to him or even Ray Bourque. But being a point-per-game backend player will put you into the greatest player conversation. As will winning two Norris Trophies. Every player who has won multiple is in the Hockey Hall of Fame, aside from the still active Duncan Keith and Erik Karlsson, who each will get that call one day.

Makar was named a Norris finalist on Monday but is likely to lose the award to Roman Josi. Of course, MacKinnon’s praise comes as Makar leads the Avs past Josi’s Preds. While Josi may take home his second Norris, it’s evident that Makar is the better player right now after that series. So yeah, Makar might let this year’s Norris slip, but winning a Stanley Cup and Conn Smythe is better for the resume anyway.


Nazem Kadri...
Will Petersen

Nazem Kadri’s wife shares screenshots of sickening racist threats

Mike Stephens of Sports Illustrated posted the screenshots on Twitter if you want to see them. A warning that the language is threatening and racist
1 day ago
SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - NOVEMBER 19: Nazem Kadri #91 of the Colorado Avalanche looks on against the S...
Dan Jacobs

The time has come for the Denver media to apologize to Nazem Kadri

After one of the most-memorable performances in Avalanche history, the team's much-maligned center has forced the local press to eat crow
1 day ago
Nazem Kadri...
Jake Shapiro

The Kadri Game: Nazem notches legendary hat trick after racism, threats

Nazem Kadri just turned in one of the most legendary playoff performances in Avalanche history, defeating the Blues and silencing racism
2 days ago
Nazem Kadri...
James Merilatt

Nazem Kadri taunts Blues fans after scoring not once, but twice

After scoring two second-period goals in Game 4, public enemy No. 1 in St. Louis let the Blues fans know that he appreciated their jeers
2 days ago
Devon Toews...
Jake Shapiro

WATCH: Avs tie it up, take lead, add insurance; scoring 3 in 92 seconds

The Colorado Avalanche got three quick in Game 4 against the St. Louis Blues, earning a second period lead
2 days ago
Rachel Vigil

WATCH: Behind the scenes look at Avs/Blues game 1 and 2

In the Sports Office with Rachel Vigil gives fans the behind the scenes access to all their favorite teams. This week, Rachel takes you with her as she heads out to Ball Arena for games one and two of the Avs/Blues series!
2 days ago
Could Cale Makar go down as the greatest defenseman ever?