The reasons to pursue Aaron Rodgers far outweigh the reasons not to

Mar 8, 2022, 6:40 AM
CHICAGO, IL - SEPTEMBER 05: Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (12) walks out of the locke...
(Photo by Robin Alam/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
(Photo by Robin Alam/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

I am obsessed with Aaron Rodgers

“He’s a drama queen.”

“He’s too selfish.”

“It will cost too much to get him.”


I am all in with Aaron Rodgers and I’m confused as to why so many Broncos fans aren’t. Yes, I still believe he’ll stay in Green Bay, but that doesn’t change the fact I’ll be bummed out if he stays put.

Why do I want him here in Denver so much? Well, give me some time to explain (this is why it’s a column, not a blog).

Let’s start with the fact that I remember the Peyton Manning era here fondly. Four years of relevance. Four years of national TV games. Four years (well almost) of high-octane offense. Four years of watching the Broncos’ culture change literally overnight. Two trips to the Super Bowl and one glorious title. I can easily see that happening again with Rodgers.

Plus, what’s the alternative? Unless Plan B is a trade for Russell Wilson or Deshaun Watson, then no matter who the Broncos QB is next year, he will be the fourth best quarterback in the AFC West. That is depressing.

What puzzles me is the amount of negativity directed towards Rodgers as a Bronco. Let me try and debunk each one.

He’s a selfish drama queen. Sure, the four-time MVP, two-time reigning MVP who’s on just about every other commercial is hurting for attention. C’mon. He’s accomplished enough in his career that he doesn’t deserve to be lied to by the Packers and he should be allowed to have A voice, not THE voice when it comes to what the team is doing with personnel moves. He’s also naturally concerned that his guy, Davante Adams, gets taken care of. Everything I’ve read and heard about Rodgers and been told by people who have been around that Packers’ building say he’s the consummate teammate who guys will run though a brick wall for.

It will cost too much to get him. Draft capital? That’s your holdup? How is it that I’m told over and over and over again how important the QB position is and a few picks to get a guy that fixes my problem overnight is simply too much to give up? Whatever draft picks the Broncos lose will be made up by free agents that want to come to Denver. Also, George Paton is supposed to be this expert drafter, right? Didn’t he just cop an A grade from the scouting community? I’m trusting him to be able to do more with less.

It’s only a short-term solution. My first answer is SEE ABOVE: Peyton Manning. Secondly, yes, it would be nice to have a 15-year answer at the QB position. It would be nice to have our version of Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen or any QB who fits that bill. But, they are terribly hard to find. For every one Mahomes I can give you Sam Darnold, Josh Rosen, Dwayne Haskins, Daniel Jones and Jared Goff. If you think passing on three to four years of Rodgers because you want to take a flier on Malik Willis is the best strategy, then, all due respect, I think you’re loony.

Besides drafting a young QB in the hopes he’s THE NEXT BIG THING, I believe there’s something else in play. Watching young players spawns hope. It also brings along with it lower expectations and more patience. It’s been a chaotic, stressful, angry and discouraging last five years in Broncos Country. Drafting a Willis for example would immediately take the pressure off EVERYONE. There would be an understanding the kid couldn’t play right away or even if he did, it will take time to blossom. That’s okay to some Broncos fans; they’re not in a hurry. It’s fun to watch the development. It will be fun to watch Nathaniel Hackett coach him up. Besides, the real day of reckoning as to whether or not he’ll be our unicorn is a ways off. We can spend that time dreaming.

Most Broncos fans are also Avalanche fans and Nuggets fans. How much fun has it been to watch the slow, steady growth of Nikola Jokic, Jamal Murray, Michael Porter Jr., Nathan MacKinnon, Gabe Landeskog, Mikko Rantanen and Cale Makar? There has been no real expectations placed on those teams until now with the Avs and probably next season with the Nuggets. But for fans, it’s been fun to watch these young studs grow up as OURS. Years of just enjoying the process without any real pressure and angst. Not a bad world to live in as a sports fan. I believe we’re seeing some of that here with the Broncos and the push to draft a young QB.

Someday, I might be on board with that. Not now. Not with Rodgers so within our grasp. Bring him to me. I’ll take him. Gladly, With no reservations.


Drop the Mike

Avalanche win Game 1...
Mike Evans

The Stanley Cup being back in Denver brings back a flood of memories

Wednesday night provided a reminder of just how special these types of moments are for a city, bringing everyone together for one goal
11 days ago
Jared Bednar...
Mike Evans

The Avalanche handled their first gut check of the postseason

With a crucial win in Game 3, Colorado took a huge step toward exorcising the demons of past playoff failures, a huge hurdle in Mission 16W
1 month ago
Nikola Jokic...
Mike Evans

Now that he’s won another MVP, the real work begins for Nikola Jokic

To go from being in select company to an elite fraternity, the Nuggets center has to take his team to the next level and deliver a championship
2 months ago
Devon Toews...
Mike Evans

Even after one game, it’s clear these aren’t the same old Avalanche

While plenty of fans are still being cautious due to previous playoff failures, this Avalanche team is ready to exorcise those demons
2 months ago
Greg Dulcich...
Mike Evans

Never been so glad to suffer through a boring Broncos draft

Due to the Russell Wilson trade, Denver sat idly by for the marquee part of the NFL Draft, which was just fine in Broncos Country
2 months ago
Nikola Jokic...
Mike Evans

There are no excuses, but the Nuggets are simply overmatched

While blaming the officials and coaching is convenient, the reality of playoff basketball is coming through; the Warriors are more talented
2 months ago
The reasons to pursue Aaron Rodgers far outweigh the reasons not to