BRONCOS

Should Broncos turn to “retread” head coach?

Nov 18, 2021, 6:30 AM | Updated: 6:33 am

History has looked favorably on so-called “retread” coaches through the past two decades of the NFL, especially when it comes to the Denver Broncos.

For example, the Broncos’ three Super Bowl titles were won under the guidance of head coaches in their second job — Gary Kubiak and Mike Shanahan.

Also, the winningest coach (by winning percentage) in Broncos history is John Fox, who was in his second stint at the helm of an NFL franchise when he helped lead Denver to four consecutive AFC West crowns from 2011 to 2014.

“This century, 15 of the 22 Super Bowl championships were won by head coaches on their second job — from Bill Belichick to Andy Reid to Bruce Arians to Gary Kubiak to Pete Carroll to Tom Coughlin and Tony Dungy to Jon Gruden to Dick Vermeil,” said “Schlereth & Evans” co-host Mike Evans on Wednesday.

But, should the Broncos blow out its coaching staff at the end of the season, as many expect, would a “retread” head coach be the right fit?

“I’ve always been a fan of guys that have done it before because you learn during your first tenure the mistakes and the things you don’t want to repeat again,” said “Schlereth & Evans” co-host Mark Schlereth. “At least you should.”

Schlereth said one of the adjustments first-time head coaches have is learning how to leave their coordinator ways behind them.

“I think a lot of guys have a tough time letting go of coaching on a day-to-day basis. … They don’t see the forest through the trees. They’re too involved,” Schlereth said. “Whereas it was always explained to me, and I believe this to be true, your head coach’s job is to coach the coaches. And I think it’s hard to let go of some of that connectivity you have with players because they energize a lot of guys.

“That’s why there’s some guys that are just really good coordinators and never, ever make it as head coaches because they just can’t transition into what the head coach’s job is.”

Schlereth said he believes head coaches can learn a lot from their first stint as a head coach, however, and that “sometimes it takes getting fired before you can step back and look at the totality, look at it from a global perspective, and say, ‘These are really good things I did. These things need to change.’”

But what about the young, up-and-coming head coaches popping up throughout the league, like Matt LaFleur or Sean McDermott or Sean McVay?

“Should you be looking for the next Bruce Arians, Bill Belichick, Mike Shanahan, Gary Kubiak, John Fox, or should you be looking for the next McDermott, LaFleur, McVay, Vrabel, that type?” Evans asked.

Said Schlereth: “I don’t think there’s a right answer. I think you have to know when you know.”

Broncos

George Paton J.J. McCarthy...

Andrew Mason

George Paton: Round 1 isn’t the only place where Broncos can find a quarterback

For Broncos general manager George Paton, the draft able answer to the Broncos’ quarterback quandary doesn’t have to come in the first round. “I do think it is a good quarterback class. There’s seven, eight quarterbacks that we like that (we) think can play in the league one day,” Paton said during a pre-draft press […]

4 hours ago

Sean Payton George Paton Broncos...

Will Petersen

Sean Payton, George Paton asked directly if Broncos will take QB

"If we had the tip sheets as to who everyone else was taking it'd be easier to answer that question," Broncos head coach Sean Payton said

8 hours ago

Courtland Sutton...

Will Petersen

ESPN suggests Broncos could use Courtland Sutton to trade up

This mock is a bit quirky, as Bill Barnwell proposes a trade for every team, but he sees the Broncos with potential to get to No. 4 overall

11 hours ago

Byron Murphy...

Cecil Lammey

The Broncos can bolster their d-line with mid-round picks in 2024

Denver needs to get better in the trenches, something they can do on the defensive side of the ball in the middle rounds of the draft

15 hours ago

Bo Nix Broncos mock draft...

Andrew Mason

The Broncos may want to move down in the draft — but they may not have a trade partner to do it

The best Broncos draft plan might be to trade down ... but what if they can't find any partners who want to move up to their No. 12 spot?

1 day ago

HOUSTON, TEXAS - JANUARY 08: J.J. McCarthy #9 of the Michigan Wolverines answers questions during t...

Cecil Lammey

Is Staying at 12 the right strategy for the Broncos to find their QB?

The Denver Broncos may have to stay at no12 overall in the 2024 NFL draft. Is that the best plan to find a QB? Watch Orange and Blue Today with Cecil Lammey and Andrew Mason! Follow @CecilLammey

1 day ago

Should Broncos turn to “retread” head coach?